Is Astrophytum a cactus or succulent?
Astrophytum is a cactus, a genus of 6 accepted species in the family Cactaceae, native from southern Texas to Mexico. Every cactus stores water in its stem, so it is also a succulent; cactus is the more exact name.
What settles it is the areole, a felted cushion that grows spines, hair and flowers. Only cacti have areoles, and spineless species carry them too: on A. asterias they are the woolly dots along each rib. White flecks between them are tufts of hair, a mark of the genus. The areole test for cactus or succulent works on any plant.
Succulent is a loose label for plants with water-storing leaves or stems, not a plant family. All cacti are succulents, but plenty of succulents are not cacti.
At rarecactus.com every name is checked against Kew POWO, which counts 6 species in Astrophytum where older books list 4 or 5.
